India’s Minerals Policy Needs to Move to Material Security
Context
- Critical minerals have become essential for modern industrial development, technological advancement and national security.
- Minerals such as lithium, cobalt, nickel and rare earth elements are crucial for electric vehicles (EVs), batteries, electronics, renewable energy and strategic industries.
- As India pursues manufacturing expansion and a clean energy transition, securing a reliable supply of these minerals has become a major policy priority.
- The government has strengthened its critical minerals strategy through financial investments, legislative reforms and institutional initiatives.
Strengthening India’s Critical Minerals Policy
- The government has elevated critical minerals within its economic and strategic priorities.
- The National Critical Mineral Mission (NCMM) received an allocation of ₹34,300 crore for a seven-year programme covering exploration, mining and processing.
- Amendments to mining legislation have enabled the auction of blocks containing 24 critical minerals, with further auctions expected before 2031.
- These initiatives reflect India’s recognition that critical minerals are essential for industrial competitiveness, energy transition and technological self-reliance.
- However, their success depends on establishing an integrated ecosystem covering exploration, extraction, processing, refining and recycling.
Beyond the Auctions: Building Processing and Refining Capacity
- Extracted ores require beneficiation and refining to remove impurities and convert them into usable industrial materials.
- India remains vulnerable because it imports most of its critical and processed materials. Expanding domestic mining without developing processing infrastructure could perpetuate this dependence.
- China’s dominance in critical mineral supply chains demonstrates the importance of processing and refining capabilities.
- Its influence comes not merely from mining but from its ability to process minerals on a large scale.
- India must therefore recognise that mineral availability and material availability are different.
- Mining and processing facilities must develop simultaneously, despite challenges such as environmental clearances, land acquisition, inadequate infrastructure and technological limitations.
Tapping the Recycling Industry
- Critical mineral recycling offers an alternative to dependence on newly established mines.
- Recovering minerals from electronic waste, discarded batteries and industrial residues can strengthen domestic supplies while reducing environmental pressures.
- Under the NCMM, a recycling scheme targets the recovery of 400 kilotonnes of critical minerals by 2031, supported by an allocation of ₹1,500 crore.
- It covers tailings, fly ash, red mud and end-of-life products.
- According to Redseer, India generated 3.8 million metric tonnes of e-waste in 2024. Growing electronic consumption, electric mobility and battery storage will further increase recyclable material availability.
- Recycling can provide critical minerals faster than developing new mines and promote a circular economy.
Challenges in Establishing an Effective Recycling Ecosystem
- India’s recycling industry remains fragmented, creating difficulties in systematic waste collection and mineral recovery.
- Two priorities require attention:
- Collection and traceability: Recyclers need predictable access to electronic waste, discarded batteries and industrial residues.
- Quality assurance: Manufacturers require recovered materials with consistent purity, composition and reliability.
- Organised collection networks, formal recycling operations and appropriate quality standards are essential for integrating recycled minerals into industrial supply chains.
Stockpiling: A Short-Term Security Measure, Not a Long-Term Solution
- A national strategic stockpile of critical minerals can protect India against sudden international supply disruptions.
- Export restrictions imposed by mineral-producing countries have demonstrated the vulnerability of global supply chains.
- Strategic reserves can provide temporary protection to industries against shortages and price fluctuations. However, stockpiling alone cannot guarantee long-term mineral security.
- The government must determine which minerals should be stored, appropriate inventory levels and replenishment requirements.
- Technological advancements may also change the strategic importance of particular minerals over time.
- Therefore, strategic reserves should complement domestic mining, processing and recycling rather than substitute for them.
Implementation: The Real Test of India’s Mineral Strategy
- India has made considerable progress through financial allocations, legislative reforms and institutional frameworks.
- Nevertheless, effective implementation remains the greatest challenge.
- Developing advanced processing facilities and reliable recycling networks requires sustained investment, technological expertise and coordination between government and industry.
- India must prioritise:
- Expanding domestic exploration and mining.
- Developing advanced beneficiation and refining technologies.
- Encouraging private investment and international collaboration.
- Strengthening recycling infrastructure and waste collection.
- Establishing strategic reserves against temporary disruptions.
- Promoting research into alternative materials and mineral recovery.
- These measures are essential for reducing import dependence and building resilient domestic supply chains.
Conclusion
- India’s critical minerals strategy has entered an important phase. However, mineral ownership is not equivalent to material security.
- The next stage must focus on domestic processing, refining, recycling and carefully planned strategic reserves.
- Ultimately, India’s technological self-reliance, manufacturing competitiveness and clean energy transition will depend not on the number of mineral blocks auctioned but on its ability to transform natural resources into reliable industrial materials.
- The transition from mineral resource availability to material security must become the central objective of India’s critical minerals policy.
India’s Minerals Policy Needs to Move to Material Security FAQs
Q1. What is the National Critical Mineral Mission?
Ans. The National Critical Mineral Mission is a seven-year programme with an allocation of ₹34,300 crore for critical mineral exploration, mining and processing.
Q2. Why are mineral auctions insufficient for ensuring mineral security?
Ans. Mineral auctions alone are insufficient because extracted minerals require beneficiation, processing and refining before industrial use.
Q3. How can recycling strengthen India’s critical mineral supply?
Ans. Recycling can recover valuable minerals from e-waste, discarded batteries and industrial residues, reducing import dependence.
Q4. What is the purpose of a strategic mineral stockpile?
Ans. A strategic stockpile protects industries against temporary supply disruptions and international export restrictions.
Q5. What is India’s biggest challenge in achieving critical mineral security?
Ans. India’s biggest challenge is developing integrated domestic mining, processing, refining and recycling capabilities to ensure reliable material supplies.
Source: The Hindu
The Changing Dynamic of Nationalism in India
Context
- Despite predictions that modernity and developed capitalism would weaken national and ethnic identities, nationalism continues to shape political and social relationships.
- Its character depends on the principles on which national identity is constructed.
- In India, the growing tension between the inclusive nationalism of the freedom struggle and the assertion of exclusionary ethnic nationalism has become an important concern.
- Understanding this transformation requires examining civic and ethnic nationalism and their implications for democracy, social justice and economic equality.
Two Forms of Nationalism
-
Civic Nationalism: An Inclusive Democratic Framework
- Civic nationalism is based on shared constitutional values such as liberty, equality, justice, fraternity and secularism.
- It unites people belonging to different religions, languages, cultures and social backgrounds.
- Its essential features include:
- Inclusiveness: Accommodating diverse communities without imposing cultural uniformity.
- Democratic values: Respecting constitutional institutions, individual freedoms and fundamental rights.
- Social justice: Addressing historical discrimination and marginalisation.
- Respect for diversity: Allowing different identities to flourish.
- Emancipation: Challenging oppressive social structures and promoting equality.
-
Ethnic Nationalism: An Exclusionary Identity
- Ethnic nationalism defines national identity through a dominant religion, language, race or culture.
- It privileges one identity and marginalises those who do not conform to it.
- Unlike civic nationalism, it is exclusionary and threatens pluralism and individual freedoms.
- Nazi Germany under Hitler provides a historical example.
- Its ideology of Aryan racial superiority resulted in systematic persecution and genocide, particularly against Jews.
-
The Inclusive Legacy of India’s Freedom Struggle
- Indian nationalism during the freedom struggle was predominantly civic and anti-imperialist.
- It united diverse communities against colonial rule through shared aspirations for freedom, equality, secularism and justice.
- The adoption of the Indian Constitution institutionalised this inclusive vision through fundamental rights, individual freedoms and equality before the law.
- It also challenged oppressive institutions such as the caste system.
- The Constitution represented the emancipatory possibilities of democratic nationalism, recognising that national development required rational thinking, scientific temper, social reform and democratic participation.
Exclusionary Nature of Present Nationalism
-
Shift Towards Ethnic and Majoritarian Nationalism
- The dominant political expression of nationalism in India over the last decade has increasingly emphasised religious identity and cultural uniformity.
- The assertion of Hindutva-based ethnic nationalism privileges a particular religious-cultural identity as the defining characteristic of the nation.
- Consequently, religious minorities, Dalits, Adivasis and other marginalised communities risk exclusion.
- Violence against individuals accused of storing beef or skinning dead animals illustrates the growing insecurity associated with religious and cultural differences.
-
Patriarchy and Masculinisation of Nationalism
- Contemporary ethnic nationalism is closely associated with patriarchal social structures.
- Women face restrictions regarding clothing, behaviour and personal choices, undermining their bodily autonomy.
- Women’s participation in protests and criticism of government policies can also provoke hostility.
- This reflects the relationship between patriarchy and majoritarian nationalism, both of which seek to reinforce established hierarchies and restrict individual freedom.
-
Suppression of Dissent and Alternative National Imaginations
- Political scientist Benedict Anderson described a nation as an imagined political community.
- However, nations can accommodate multiple imaginations based on democracy, diversity and social justice.
- Problems arise when one political imagination attempts to delegitimise all alternatives.
- A healthy democracy requires freedom of expression, peaceful protest and criticism of government policies.
- Suppressing dissent weakens constitutional democracy and reduces nationalism to unquestioning political loyalty.
-
Ethnic Nationalism and the Threat of Fascism
- Extreme ethnic nationalism can develop authoritarian and fascistic characteristics.
- Philosopher Jason Stanley identifies features of fascism, including glorification of a mythical past, anti-intellectualism, propaganda and the creation of internal enemies.
- Economist Prabhat Patnaik highlights the imperialist character of European nationalism, historically associated with colonial expansion.
- In contrast, Indian nationalism emerged primarily through an anti-imperialist struggle.
- Therefore, adopting exclusionary European models contradicts India’s historical experience.
The Role of Corporate Capitalism
-
Alliance Between Corporate Interests and Ethnic Nationalism
- Capitalism periodically experiences crises involving unemployment, declining profitability and economic inequality.
- Such conditions can generate demands for redistribution and structural reforms.
- Right-wing nationalism can divert public attention from economic difficulties towards religious and cultural conflicts.
- This helps protect established economic interests from growing public dissatisfaction.
-
Weakening Class Consciousness and Social Solidarity
- Ethnic nationalism divides society along religious and cultural lines, weakening collective struggles for economic and social justice.
- It prevents disadvantaged communities from developing common platforms against inequality and exploitation.
- Both corporate capitalism and exclusionary nationalism have an uncomfortable relationship with substantive equality.
- Their convergence can weaken demands for redistribution, workers’ rights and democratic accountability.
Conclusion
- India must recover the inclusive, constitutional and anti-imperialist nationalism that shaped its freedom struggle.
- National unity cannot emerge through cultural uniformity, discrimination or suppression of dissent.
- It must rest on constitutional values, secularism, gender equality, social justice and respect for diversity.
- True patriotism lies in defending democratic freedoms, protecting marginalised communities and preserving the pluralistic character of the nation.
The Changing Dynamic of Nationalism in India FAQs
Q1. What is civic nationalism?
Ans. Civic nationalism is based on shared constitutional values such as liberty, equality, justice, fraternity and secularism.
Q2. How does ethnic nationalism differ from civic nationalism?
Ans. Ethnic nationalism privileges a dominant identity and excludes communities that do not conform to it.
Q3. Who described a nation as an “imagined political community”?
Ans. Political scientist Benedict Anderson described a nation as an “imagined political community.”
Q4. How does ethnic nationalism threaten democracy?
Ans. It marginalises minorities, suppresses dissent and undermines constitutional freedoms and social equality.
Q5. How does corporate capitalism benefit from ethnic nationalism?
Ans. It diverts public attention from economic inequality and weakens collective struggles for social and economic justice.
Source: The Hindu
Shenzhen Trilateral – Great-Power Politics and the Future of Multilateralism
Context:
- The meeting of US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen raises concerns about the future of the post-World War II, rules-based international order.
- Their shared scepticism towards multilateral institutions and preference for personalised diplomacy, bilateral bargaining and power politics may accelerate the shift towards a more fragmented, multipolar world order.
- Although the meeting may not signal a definitive realignment, it reflects the growing influence of great-power diplomacy over institutionalised multilateral cooperation.
Changing Foreign Policy Approaches of the Three Powers:
-
China under Xi Jinping – An alternative global order:
- Since 2012, China has pursued a more assertive and expansionist foreign policy, seeking a greater role in global governance.
- It has established or strengthened alternative institutions and arrangements, including AIIB, BRI, RCEP, and BRICS, where China has emerged as a dominant influence.
- Paradoxically, China’s economic rise has also benefited significantly from Western-led trade liberalisation, contributing to growing protectionist sentiments in the US.
-
Russia under Putin – Multipolarity and spheres of influence:
- Russia has consistently challenged the US-led international order and advocated a multipolar world.
- Its actions include the 2014 annexation of Crimea and the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, challenging established principles of sovereignty and territorial integrity.
- It advocates negotiated spheres of influence for major powers and has strengthened strategic, economic and security partnerships with China and Iran.
-
US under Trump – America First and unilateralism:
- Despite being the principal architect and defender of the post-war international order, the US under Trump has increasingly questioned its institutions.
- Trump has criticised the WTO and NATO, favouring bilateral negotiations over multilateral arrangements.
- His tariff wars have weakened confidence in rules-based global trade and encouraged unilateral economic coercion.
- Personalised diplomacy and direct engagement with national leaders have increasingly bypassed established diplomatic institutions.
Shenzhen Trilateral:
- The meeting has drawn comparisons with the 1945 Yalta Conference, where the US, Britain and the Soviet Union discussed the post-war international order.
- However, unlike Yalta, the Shenzhen meeting took place amid intensifying geopolitical rivalries.
- The joint statement emphasised maintaining strategic stability and international security, suggesting an attempt to identify common ground rather than conclude a comprehensive strategic agreement.
Four Major Areas of Understanding and Their Symbolism:
-
UN reforms:
- The leaders supported reforms to make the United Nations more responsive to global challenges.
- However, the nature and extent of proposed reforms remain unclear, despite the UN’s outdated representation of contemporary geopolitical realities.
- Energy security: They proposed increasing the production and supply of refined petroleum products. This is significant for India, a major global refining hub, particularly amid disruptions to international energy supplies.
-
International Criminal Court (ICC):
- The leaders cautioned against the alleged misuse of jurisdiction by the ICC and similar bodies.
- This aligns with Russia’s opposition to the ICC arrest warrant against Putin over alleged war crimes. None of the three countries is a party to the Rome Statute.
-
Nuclear security:
- They agreed to engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation.
- However, this does not amount to a commitment to reduce their own nuclear arsenals. The reference to non-proliferation also carries implications for Iran.
-
Historical symbolism:
- Xi invoked World War II as the backbone of the global anti-fascist struggle, while Putin highlighted the three countries as victorious powers.
- These references underline the continuing importance of the 1945 legacy in shaping their geopolitical narratives, including messages directed towards Japan and Europe.
Implications for Multilateralism and Global Governance:
-
Shift towards personalised great-power diplomacy:
- Institutionalised cooperation, collective deliberation and common norms may increasingly give way to direct negotiations among powerful leaders.
- Excluding Ukraine and European powers from discussions concerning the Ukraine conflict risks legitimising decisions by a handful of powerful states over affected countries.
-
Emergence of a new global hierarchy:
- The meeting reinforces perceptions of multipolarity by bringing three major powers together.
- However, it may replace the existing hierarchy with another dominated by powerful states rather than establish an inclusive international order.
-
Marginalisation of international institutions:
- The growing preference for leader-level negotiations could weaken the role of institutions in resolving disputes and establishing global norms.
- Institutions such as the UN may increasingly become platforms for endorsing decisions already negotiated outside their frameworks.
-
Fragmentation of multilateralism:
- Rather than witnessing the complete decline of multilateralism, the world may experience competing versions of it, shaped by different power centres and strategic interests.
- The role of emerging economies and the Global South in these alternative arrangements remains uncertain.
India’s Strategic Priorities:
- Strategic autonomy: Maintain independent foreign policy choices and avoid excessive dependence on any single power bloc.
- Diversified partnerships: Strengthen cooperation with like-minded countries through platforms such as the Quad, BRICS and G20.
- Institutional reforms: Advocate democratisation of global governance, particularly reforms in the UN Security Council, to provide greater representation to the Global South.
- Economic resilience: Strengthen domestic manufacturing, supply-chain diversification and energy security to reduce external vulnerabilities.
- Technological capabilities: Invest in indigenous research, critical technologies, semiconductors and defence production to enhance strategic autonomy.
- Constructive multilateralism: Support inclusive, rules-based international cooperation while engaging pragmatically with competing power centres.
Conclusion:
- The Shenzhen trilateral may not mark the end of multilateralism, but it reflects its transformation.
- Hence, the emerging international order could witness multiple competing forms of multilateralism rather than a single universally accepted framework.
Shenzhen Trilateral FAQs
Q1. How does the Shenzhen trilateral reflect the changing nature of multilateralism?
Ans. It reflects a shift from institutionalised, rules-based cooperation towards personalised diplomacy.
Q2. Why is China’s approach challenging the US-led international order?
Ans. Through initiatives such as BRI, AIIB and BRICS, China is promoting alternative structures of global governance.
Q3. What are the major implications of great-power diplomacy for global governance?
Ans. It risks marginalising smaller states, weakening international institutions and promoting exclusive great-power decision-making.
Q4. How does the emerging global order pose challenges for India’s strategic autonomy?
Ans. Intensifying US-China-Russia competition may require diversified partnerships.
Q5. What should be India’s approach towards the emerging multipolar world order?
Ans. India should pursue strategic autonomy, strengthen domestic industrial and technological capabilities.
Last updated on Nov, 2026
→ UPSC Interview 2026 is scheduled from 7 December 2026 to 12 February 2027.
→ UPSC Interview Guidance Programme (IGP) 2026 by Vajiram & Ravi helps aspirants prepare confidently for the UPSC Personality Test.
→ UPSC DAF 2026 application form is available from 11 to 25 November 2026, till 6:00 PM.
→ UPSC 2027 Notification will be released on 13 January 2027 at upsconline.nic.in.
→ Download PIB PRiSM Monthly Magazine 2026 here.
→ Check UPSC Monthly Current Affairs Magazine The Recitals here.
→ Check out the latest UPSC Syllabus here.
→ UPSC Calendar 2027 has been released.
→ Enroll in Vajiram & Ravi’s UPSC Mains Test Series 2027 for structured answer writing practice, expert evaluation, and exam-oriented feedback.
→ Join Vajiram & Ravi’s UPSC Mentorship Program 2027 for personalized guidance, strategy planning, and one-to-one support from experienced mentors.
→ Go through the UPSC Mains Previous Year Papers to enhance your preparation.
→ UPSC has released UPSC Toppers List 2025 with the Civil Services final result on its official website.
→ Also check Best UPSC Coaching in India
Daily Editorial Analysis 2026 FAQs
Q1. What is editorial analysis?+
Q2. What is an editorial analyst?+
Q3. What is an editorial for UPSC?+
Q4. What are the sources of UPSC Editorial Analysis?+
Q5. Can Editorial Analysis help in Mains Answer Writing?+
Tags: daily editorial analysis the hindu editorial analysis the indian express analysis






