What Iran’s Withdrawal from the NPT Could Mean for Global Nuclear Stability

Iran NPT withdrawal

Iran NPT Withdrawal Latest News

  • In the wake of rising military tensions, Iran's Parliament is drafting a Bill to potentially withdraw from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). 
  • This move follows recent Israeli airstrikes on Iranian nuclear facilities, citing concerns that Iran was nearing weapons-grade uranium enrichment.

About The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT)

  • The NPT is a global treaty signed in 1968 and entered into force in 1970, aimed at:
    • Preventing the spread of nuclear weapons and technology
    • Promoting peaceful uses of nuclear energy
    • Supporting nuclear disarmament

Background: Post-World War II Nuclear Concerns

  • After the atomic bombings in Japan (1945), nations began a nuclear arms race. 
  • Alongside, efforts emerged to limit the proliferation of nuclear weapons and technology.

Atoms for Peace Initiative (1953)

  • Launched by U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower
  • Advocated for the peaceful use of nuclear energy
  • Paved the way for the formation of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA)
  • Introduced a safeguards system to monitor and verify civilian nuclear activities

Safeguards and Verification

  • Non-nuclear weapon states must submit detailed reports on nuclear activities
  • Allow IAEA inspections to prevent diversion of nuclear materials for weapons
  • Part of the “basic bargain”: peaceful nuclear assistance in exchange for oversight

Definition of Nuclear States under the NPT

  • Nuclear states are those that tested nuclear weapons before January 1, 1967.
  • This included:
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • France
    • Soviet Union (now Russia)
    • China

Membership and Non-Signatories

  • 191 countries are parties to the treaty
  • Non-signatories include:
    • India: Conducted nuclear tests in 1974; opposes the discriminatory nature of the treaty
    • Pakistan: Not a signatory
    • Israel: Neither confirms nor denies nuclear weapons possession; hasn’t signed
    • North Korea: Signed in 1985, withdrew in 2003, expelled IAEA inspectors

Criticism

  • Viewed as discriminatory for legitimizing nuclear weapons only for the P5 (UNSC permanent members).
  • The 1967 cut-off date is seen as arbitrary, reinforcing a nuclear hierarchy.

How Can a Country Leave the NPT

  • Under Article 10 of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT):
    • A country may withdraw if extraordinary events jeopardize its supreme national interests.
    • It must notify all treaty parties and the UN Security Council three months in advance, citing those events.

Iran's NPT Membership and Recent Developments

  • Iran joined the NPT in 1970, prior to its Islamic Revolution (1979).
  • For the first time in nearly 20 years, the IAEA Board of Governors recently censured Iran, citing:
    • Repeated failure since 2019 to cooperate fully with the agency.
    • Discovery of undeclared nuclear material and activities at multiple sites.
  • Iran’s Response
    • Iran denied violations, stating it has adhered to its safeguards obligations under the NPT.
    • However, tensions have grown, particularly after recent Israeli strikes and Iran’s retaliatory missile attacks.

Implications of Iran Withdrawing from the NPT

  • End of IAEA Oversight
    • Iran would no longer be subject to IAEA inspections, which averaged 1.4 site visits per day in 2023.
    • This would reduce international visibility into Iran’s nuclear activities.
  • Risk of Destabilizing the Global Non-Proliferation Regime
    • Iran’s withdrawal could set a precedent for other states to follow.
    • Could lead to a weakening of global cooperation on nuclear non-proliferation.
  • Does Withdrawal Mean Weaponization
    • Leaving the NPT does not automatically imply Iran will build nuclear weapons.
    • However, historical cases (e.g., North Korea) show that withdrawal may precede weapon development.
    • Iran has denied such intentions, but regional instability fuels uncertainty.
  • Scholarly Perspective: The Value of NPT
    • Experts argue that:
      • Even imperfect adherence can significantly slow nuclear proliferation.
      • A global treaty can maintain normative pressure until a tipping point is reached, beyond which violations could undermine the regime altogether.

Source: IE | NYT | MSNBC

Iran NPT Withdrawal FAQs

Q1: What is the NPT’s main objective?

Ans: To prevent nuclear weapons spread, promote peaceful nuclear energy, and encourage disarmament through global cooperation.

Q2: Can countries legally exit the NPT?

Ans: Yes, by citing extraordinary threats to national interests and giving three months’ notice to treaty members and the UNSC.

Q3: Why is Iran considering leaving the NPT?

Ans: Due to IAEA censure and escalating tensions with Israel over alleged nuclear weapons development.

Q4: What happens if Iran exits the treaty?

Ans: Iran would no longer face IAEA inspections, reducing oversight and raising nuclear proliferation concerns.

Q5: Will NPT withdrawal lead to nuclear arms?

Ans: Not necessarily, but history shows it increases the risk and undermines global non-proliferation frameworks.

Enquire Now