Pax Silica and MSP: Why India Joined Late

Pax Silica

Pax Silica Latest News

  • India’s belated induction into US-led initiatives like Minerals Security Partnership and Pax Silica has evoked a sense of déjà vu among policymakers. 
  • As with MSP—where India joined a year after launch—its entry into Pax Silica came after the initiative was already underway, seen largely as a conciliatory gesture amid efforts to steady bilateral ties.
  • The significance lies in what these groupings signal about the emerging global tech order, especially as countries reorganise supply chains in strategic sectors with Chinese presence.
  • Platforms like Pax Silica could shape rules by addressing chokepoints in inputs such as magnets and critical minerals—effectively determining where leverage will sit.
  • India’s initial exclusion, followed by a late inclusion, carries a subtle message: strategic goodwill alone may not suffice. 
  • To be a partner of first choice in US-led initiatives, India must be seen as bringing tangible capabilities and value to the table in shaping resilient, rules-setting supply chains.

About Pax Silica

  • Pax Silica is a US-led strategic initiative aimed at countering China’s dominance in next-generation technologies. 
  • It seeks to reduce “coercive dependencies” and protect materials and capabilities foundational to artificial intelligence, enabling aligned nations to develop and deploy transformative technologies at scale.

Objectives and Scope

  • According to the US State Department, Pax Silica is designed to build a secure, prosperous, and innovation-driven silicon supply chain.
  • It aims to ensure access across the entire AI stack—from critical minerals and semiconductor chips to security and logistics infrastructure.

Key Thrust Areas Under Pax Silica

  • Under Pax Silica, participating countries aim to:
    • Pursue joint ventures and strategic co-investments
    • Protect sensitive technologies and critical infrastructure from undue foreign control
    • Build trusted technology ecosystems spanning ICT systems, fibre-optic cables, data centres, foundational AI models, and applications

Founding Members and Their Strengths

  • The inaugural Pax Silica Summit brought together Japan, the Republic of Korea, Singapore, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, Israel, the United Arab Emirates, and Australia
  • These countries collectively host key companies and investors that power the global AI and semiconductor supply chain, reflecting their technological or resource-based leverage.

Why India Was Initially Excluded from Pax Silica

  • Pax Silica aims to secure supply chains spanning critical minerals, energy inputs, advanced manufacturing, and semiconductors. 
  • India’s initial absence reflects perceptions that it lacks decisive edge technologies or control over key resources central to the grouping’s objectives.

What the Selected Countries Bring

  • Each of the eight founding members offers a distinct strategic advantage:
    • The Netherlands controls specialised lithography machines vital for chipmaking.
    • Japan and South Korea bring deep technology and manufacturing expertise.
    • Australia contributes critical mineral reserves and mining capabilities.
    • Israel is a global innovation and technology hub.
    • Singapore serves as a major transhipment and logistics hub.
    • The UK offers strengths in services and technology.
    • The UAE has rapidly built AI capabilities and supporting infrastructure.

A Familiar Pattern from MSP

  • A similar logic shaped the initial membership of the Minerals Security Partnership, where early partners included countries with clear mineral, technology, or institutional advantages. 
  • India joined later, despite its efforts to position itself as a node in global supply-chain realignment as firms diversify away from China.

The Takeaway for India

  • The common thread among the founding members is a tangible lead in AI or semiconductor supply chains—an area where India currently lacks comparable processing capacity and expertise. 
  • As with earlier initiatives such as the MSP, this gap explains India’s absence at the outset.
  • The exclusion underscores a consistent message: entry into US-led strategic groupings hinges on demonstrable capabilities and leverage—not just intent. 
  • To be a first-choice partner, India must strengthen its control over critical inputs, technologies, or platforms that shape supply-chain rules.

Shared Challenge: China’s Critical Minerals Dominance

  • Experts point out that China’s dominance in critical minerals has created sharp global price gaps, disadvantaging non-Chinese supply chains. 
  • While this opens space for India to attract US investment, it also raises risks of Chinese coercion as India deepens alignment with Washington.
  • US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent framed China’s export controls as “China versus the rest of the world,” calling for support from Europe, India, and Asian democracies.
  • Despite this rhetoric and shared concerns, India remained outside Pax Silica’s initial list, underscoring a gap between strategic alignment and perceived capabilities.

Source: IE | IE

Pax Silica FAQs

Q1: What is Pax Silica?

Ans: Pax Silica is a US-led initiative to secure AI and semiconductor supply chains by reducing dependence on China and coordinating trusted partners across minerals, chips, and logistics.

Q2: Why is Pax Silica important for India?

Ans: Pax Silica matters for India because it signals where future leverage in AI, semiconductors, and critical minerals will lie as countries reshape global technology supply chains.

Q3: Why did India join Pax Silica late?

Ans: India joined Pax Silica late because it lacks strong processing capacity, edge technologies, and control over critical inputs compared to founding members with established leverage.

Q4: How is Pax Silica similar to MSP?

Ans: Pax Silica mirrors MSP in prioritising countries with tangible capabilities in minerals and technology, where India was initially excluded and later admitted after diplomatic lobbying.

Q5: What is the key lesson from Pax Silica for India?

Ans: Pax Silica shows India must build concrete capabilities in critical minerals, processing, and advanced manufacturing to be a first-choice partner in US-led strategic groupings.

Enquire Now