Difference Between Money Bill & Financial Bill, Articles, Key Points

Q: Can a Money Bill be introduced in the Rajya Sabha?

No. A Money Bill can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha.

Q: Is every Finance Bill a Money Bill?

No. Only those Finance Bills that contain exclusively Article 110 provisions can be certified as Money Bills. The moment a bill includes even one clause outside Article 110, it becomes a Finance Bill Category I, not a Money Bill.

Q: Who certifies a bill as a Money Bill?

The Speaker of the Lok Sabha certifies a bill as a Money Bill, and this decision is final and cannot be challenged in Parliament.

Q: Can the Rajya Sabha amend a Money Bill?

No. Rajya Sabha can only make recommendations, which the Lok Sabha may accept or reject. For Finance Bills (Category I and II), Rajya Sabha can amend, reject or delay the bill like any ordinary bill.

Q: What happens if the Rajya Sabha does not return a Money Bill within 14 days?

If Rajya Sabha does not return the Money Bill within 14 days, the bill is considered passed by both Houses, exactly in the form approved by the Lok Sabha.

Table of Contents☰

Understanding the difference between Money Bills and Financial Bills is essential because these bills form the backbone of India’s budgeting and taxation process. While both deal with government revenue and expenditure, the Constitution lays down distinct procedures, powers, and limitations for each. Money Bills enjoy a special status under Article 109 and Article 110, whereas Financial Bills are governed by Article 117 with broader legislative implications. The Difference Between Money Bill & Financial Bill have been discussed below in detail.

What is Money Bill?

Money Bill refers to a special category of legislation that deals exclusively with financial matters such as taxation, borrowing, expenditure from the Consolidated Fund of India, and other related fiscal provisions. It is defined under Article 110, which clearly states what qualifies as a Money Bill. The unique feature of a Money Bill is that it can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha has limited powers, as explained under Article 109, which allows the Upper House only to make recommendations but not to amend or reject it.

What is Finance Bill?

A Finance Bill is a legislative proposal presented every year to implement the government’s financial measures announced in the Union Budget. It deals with taxation, alteration of existing tax laws, and other revenue-related provisions. Unlike a Money Bill, a Finance Bill can include both financial and non-financial matters depending on its category (Finance Bill I or II).

Types of Finance Bill

The Constitution classifies Finance Bills into two types, based on the nature of provisions they contain and the procedure required for their passage. All Finance Bills deal with taxation or revenue matters, but not all qualify as Money Bills.

1. Financial Bills (i): Article 117 (1)

This category contains all Money Bill provisions as defined under Article 110, but it also includes additional matters that do not strictly fall under the Money Bill definition. Since it contains non-Money Bill provisions, it is not treated as a Money Bill, even if a large part is financial.

Introduced under Article 117(1)

Requires President’s recommendation
Rajya Sabha can amend or reject (unlike a Money Bill)
Must be passed in both Houses

2. Financial Bills (ii): Article 117 (3)

This category contains provisions related to taxation or expenditure, but none of the provisions fall under Article 110 (Money Bill definition). Therefore, it is simply an Ordinary Bill dealing with finances and follows the normal legislative procedure.

Introduced under Article 117(3)
the recommendation of the President is not required at the introduction stage but is required at the consideration stage
Must be passed by both Houses of Parliament
Rajya Sabha has full powers to amend, reject, or delay

Difference Between Money Bill & Financial Bill

The difference between a Money Bill and a Financial Bill lies in their scope and constitutional treatment: Money Bills contain only Article 110 matters, while Financial Bills may include additional legislative provisions.

Difference Between Money Bill & Financial Bill
Feature	Money Bill	Finance Bill – I	Finance Bill – II
President’s Recommendation	Required before introduction.	Required before introduction.	the recommendation of the President is not required at the introduction stage but is required at the consideration stage
Role of Rajya Sabha	Cannot amend or reject; can only recommend changes.	Can amend or reject the bill.	Can amend or reject the bill.
Speaker’s Certification	Speaker of Lok Sabha decides whether it is a Money Bill.	No certification from Speaker is needed.	No certification from Speaker is needed.
Place of Introduction	Can be introduced only in Lok Sabha.	Can be introduced only in Lok Sabha.	Can be introduced in Lok Sabha or Rajya Sabha.
Joint Sitting Provision	No joint sitting allowed for resolving deadlock.	Joint sitting can be summoned by the President.	Joint sitting can be summoned by the President.
Constitutional Article	Governed by Article 110.	Governed by Article 117(1).	Governed by Article 117(3).
Scope of Provisions	Contains only matters listed in Article 110.	Contains Article 110 provisions + general legislative matters.	Relates to expenditure from Consolidated Fund of India but not covered under Article 110.

The Constitution of India lays down a structured framework to regulate how Parliament introduces, debates, and passes Money Bills and Financial Bills. Articles 110 and 117 clearly define the nature, scope, and conditions attached to each category of financial legislation.

Constitutional Provisions Related to Money and Financial Bills
Articles	Category	What It Defines / Regulates	Key Points
Article 110	Money Bill	Specifies which subjects qualify a bill as a Money Bill.	Covers taxation, government borrowings, appropriation of funds, Consolidated Fund withdrawals, and audit-related provisions.
Article 109	Money Bill	Outlines the special procedure in Rajya Sabha for Money Bills.	Rajya Sabha cannot amend or reject; may only recommend changes within 14 days.
Article 117(1)	Finance Bill – I	Financial Bills containing provisions of Article 110 plus other matters.	Requires President’s recommendation and can be introduced only in Lok Sabha.
Article 117(3)	Finance Bill – II	Financial Bills that involve expenditure from Consolidated Fund but do not fall under Article 110.	Can be introduced in either House; requires President’s recommendation if expenditure is involved.
Article 117(2)	General Financial Procedure	Restricts introduction of certain amendment bills without President’s recommendation.	Ensures executive oversight on proposals involving increased expenditure.
Article 111	Assent to Bills	Lays down the President’s power to give, withhold, or return a bill.	Money Bills cannot be returned for reconsideration.
Article 265	Taxation	States that no tax can be levied or collected without authority of law.	Forms constitutional basis for taxation powers exercised through these bills.
Article 114	Appropriation Bills	Deals with withdrawal of money from Consolidated Fund for government expenditure.	Appropriation Bills must follow the passage of the Budget.
Article 112	Annual Financial Statement	Presents the government’s estimated receipts and expenditures (Union Budget).	Forms the foundation for subsequent Money and Financial Bills.

Similarities Between Money Bills and Financial Bills

Money Bills and Financial Bills share a common purpose in shaping India’s financial governance and ensuring that public revenue and expenditure follow constitutional norms. Both types of bills deal with subjects that affect the nation’s fiscal structure, such as taxation, spending, and usage of the Consolidated Fund of India.

Similarities Between Money Bills and Financial Bills
Similarity	Explanation
Financial Nature	Both relate to financial matters such as taxation, government spending, borrowings, or fiscal administration.
Introduction During Budget Cycle	Both are commonly introduced as part of the government’s annual financial exercise and align with budget-related proposals.
Parliamentary Approval Required	Both must pass through parliamentary scrutiny and cannot become law without approval from Parliament.
Impact on Consolidated Fund of India	Both can include provisions that affect the Consolidated Fund, either by imposing charges or authorizing withdrawals.
President’s Assent Required	Both types of bills require the assent of the President before becoming law.
Can Be Government Bills	Both are introduced by the government, since financial legislation is primarily an executive responsibility.
Lok Sabha’s Primacy in Finance	In both cases, the Lok Sabha plays a central role because financial accountability is anchored in the directly elected House.
Cannot Be Ordinances Without Financial Justification	If promulgated as ordinances, both require clear financial justification and constitutional backing.