Google’s Quantum Echoes Explained: What It Really Means for Q-Day

Google’s Quantum Echoes Latest News

• Google’s new Quantum Echoes experiment used a 65-qubit quantum processor to study how information moves around inside a quantum system. 
• Unlike Google’s 2019 Sycamore experiment, which focused on speed, this work was about understanding how quantum bits behave.
• Scientists measured out-of-time-order correlators (OTOC) — tiny echoes that reveal how disturbances travel through a network of qubits.
  • Basically, scientists gave the system a tiny “poke,” reversed its evolution, and looked for a small “echo” that came back. 
  • This echo helped them see how quickly information spreads or gets scrambled among qubits. 
• These insights can help in studying new materials, superconductors, and chemical reactions.
• Even though the research is scientifically important, it does not bring us closer to Q-day — the point when quantum computers could break modern encryption. It poses no threat to security systems today.

Q-Day

• Q-day is the future moment when a powerful quantum computer can break today’s commonly used encryption systems.
• This doesn’t mean data will be exposed instantly — but anything stolen and stored today could be decoded later once such a machine exists.
  • This threat is called “harvest now, decrypt later.”

How Are Governments Preparing

• Countries are already working on protections.
• The U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has approved new post-quantum cryptography (PQC) methods designed to stay secure even against quantum computers:
  • CRYSTALS-Kyber → for encryption
  • Dilithium → for digital signatures
• These rely on tough mathematical problems that quantum computers are not expected to crack.
• Experts believe breaking RSA-2048 — a widely used encryption standard — will require millions of stable (logical) qubits.
  • RSA encryption works by multiplying two huge prime numbers.
  • Multiplying them is easy. But figuring out the original primes from the final product is extremely hard — so hard that even supercomputers would need billions of years.
• At current progress, this may take 5 to 8 years, so Q-day is still a future risk, not an immediate one.

‹ ›

How Quantum Computers Work

• Quantum computers use special units called qubits. Unlike normal bits (0 or 1), qubits can be 0 and 1 at the same time (superposition).
• They can also be entangled, meaning a change in one instantly affects another, even far away.
• Because of this, quantum computers can test many possibilities at once, making them powerful for certain tasks.

Why Quantum Computers Threaten RSA Encryption

• RSA encryption is built on the difficulty of breaking a number into its prime factors — something classical computers take billions of years to do.
• But quantum computers can use Shor’s algorithm, which turns the factoring challenge into a search for hidden repeating patterns.
• The algorithm uses a special mathematical tool called the Quantum Fourier Transform (QFT) to detect these patterns.
• If a quantum computer can run this algorithm on a large scale, it could break RSA encryption exponentially faster than classical computers.

The Problem: Today’s Quantum Computers Are Too Small

• Breaking a strong key like RSA-2048 requires enormous quantum machines.
• A 2019 study by Google researchers estimated that breaking RSA-2048 needs:
  • About 20 million physical qubits
  • 8 hours of computation
  • Perfect error correction
• But today’s biggest quantum machines (Google’s Willow, IBM’s Condor) only have a few hundred noisy qubits.

Why We Need Millions of ‘Logical Qubits’

• Physical qubits make many errors.
• To perform long, accurate calculations, we need logical qubits — stable units created by combining many physical qubits through error correction.
• A future, powerful quantum computer would need millions of these logical qubits.
• Right now, we aren’t even close to that technology.

Shor’s Algorithm vs. Quantum Echoes: Why They Are Not the Same

• Shor’s algorithm is a mathematical tool that could one day break modern encryption by rapidly factoring large numbers — something classical computers struggle to do. Its goal is computational power.
• Quantum Echoes, on the other hand, is a physics experiment. It studies how quantum information spreads and comes back like an “echo” inside entangled particles. Its purpose is scientific understanding, not breaking codes.

How Far Are We From Q-Day

• Google’s Quantum Echoes experiment does not make that day arrive sooner.
• Instead, it marks progress in understanding how quantum systems behave, not in breaking codes.
• The experiment shows that quantum processors are getting better at studying complex interactions inside entangled particles. This is a scientific milestone, not a cybersecurity threat.
• While quantum machines are slowly advancing, their biggest potential right now is in understanding nature, chemistry, and materials — not cracking RSA.
• The real challenge is making sure our digital systems become quantum-safe before quantum computers eventually reach that power. 
• The technology is evolving, but so must our defences.

Source: TH