Bnei Menashe Explained: How Bnei Menashe Forged Links with Israel

Bnei Menashe Latest News

• Around 250 members of the B’nei Menashe from Manipur and Mizoram recently arrived in Tel Aviv under an official relocation programme—the first such batch supported by the Israeli government.
• The community, numbering about 7,000 and drawn largely from Mizo and Kuki tribes, claims descent from one of the “ten lost tribes of Israel.” 
• While migration to Israel has been ongoing since the 1990s, this marks a new phase of state-backed resettlement, with more groups expected to follow.

The ‘Lost Tribes of Israel’: Origins and the B’nei Menashe Claim

• Around 722 BCE, the Assyrian conquest of Israel led to the exile of ten tribes from northern Israel. These included Reuben, Simeon, Dan, Naphtali, Gad, Asher, Issachar, Zebulun, Ephraim, and Manasseh. 
• Over time, their descendants became known as the “lost tribes of Israel”, with their whereabouts remaining uncertain.
• Global Search for Descendants – For centuries, Jewish communities worldwide have searched for traces of these tribes, including in regions like the Indian subcontinent, where several groups claim ancestral links.
• The B’nei Menashe Claim – The B’nei Menashe of Manipur and Mizoram believe they descend from the tribe of Manasseh, the largest among the lost tribes. Their name literally means “sons of Manasseh.”
• Migration Narrative and Cultural Link – According to community belief, their ancestors migrated eastward over centuries through Persia (modern Iran) and Afghanistan before settling in Northeast India.
• Role of Religious Transformation – Interestingly, the belief in Jewish ancestry gained traction after the community’s conversion to Christianity, which exposed them to biblical narratives and shaped their understanding of possible historical roots.

‹ ›

From Christianity to Judaism: The Evolution of the B’nei Menashe Identity

• The roots of the transformation trace back to 19th-century Protestant missionary activity, as noted by the analysts. 
• Missionaries introduced the Bible to local tribes, whose pre-existing belief in messianic figures helped facilitate the spread of Christianity and exposure to Israelite history.
• Christian revivalist movements (1930s–1960s) in Mizoram, combined with regional unrest and resistance in the 1960s, created conditions for reinterpreting identity. This environment encouraged some groups to seek deeper historical and religious roots.

The Turning Point: Vision of Ancestry

• A pivotal moment came in 1951, when Mizo mystic Challianthanga (Mela Chala) claimed a dream revealing that Mizo, Kuki, and Chin tribes were descendants of ancient Israelites. 
• This idea catalysed a shift toward Jewish identity.
• From the late 1970s, a structured movement toward Judaism emerged among these communities. 
• The process involved research, outreach to Jewish communities in India, and growing interest in reconnecting with Israel.

Role of Israeli Support and Organisations

• The Israeli organisation Amishav played a crucial role in guiding religious transformation and facilitating ties with Israel. 
• Institutions like the Mizo Israel Zionist Organization (1974) further formalised these efforts.
• By the 1980s, many members of the community had formally adopted Judaism, though a significant portion of the population in Manipur and Mizoram continues to remain Christian.

Re-establishing Links with Israel: Recognition, Migration, and Challenges

• Efforts were made to highlight oral histories and cultural practices linking the B’nei Menashe to Israel.
• In 2005, the Chief Rabbinate of Israel recognised them as the “Lost Seed of Israel”, based partly on inconclusive genetic studies. 
  • However, further tests by Technion – Israel Institute of Technology also remained inconclusive, keeping the scientific debate unresolved.

Migration Policies and Institutional Support

• Following recognition, Israel allowed gradual migration in small batches, sometimes pausing the process.
• In November 2025, the Israeli government approved funding for the relocation of nearly 5,000 B’nei Menashe members, marking a significant step in formal resettlement efforts.
• Despite recognition, many B’nei Menashe migrants face racial discrimination and integration challenges in Israel, particularly due to differences in physical features and cultural background.

Other ‘Lost Tribes’ Claims: Diverse Identities and Motivations

• Another Indian group, the B’nei Ephraim, claims descent from the tribe of Ephraim. 
• They believe their ancestors reached India via Central Asia about a thousand years ago.
• Belonging largely to the Dalit community, their claim to Jewish ancestry is sometimes interpreted as a way to challenge caste discrimination and seek social mobility, including recognition from global Jewish communities.

Source: IE | IT