Jurisdiction of Supreme Court, Original, Appellate, Writ & Advisory

The Jurisdiction of Supreme Court of India means the kinds of cases it has the authority to hear. As the highest court, it deals with important matters like disputes between governments, appeals from lower courts, and cases involving the protection of fundamental rights. The Jurisdiction of Supreme Court covering Original, Appellate, Writ and Advisory Jurisdiction have been discussed in detail in this article.

Original Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India

• Original jurisdiction means a case can be filed directly in the Supreme Court of India without going to lower courts first. The Court acts as the first court to hear the case.
• It mainly deals with disputes between different governments in India, such as:
  • Between the Central Government and one or more States
  • Between the Centre and States on one side and other States on the other side
  • Between two or more States
• In these matters, the Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction, which means:
  • Only the Supreme Court can hear these cases (no other court can).
  • The case starts here directly, not as an appeal.
• These disputes must involve a legal right (not just political issues) and can include questions of law or facts.
• This power is important because it:
  • Helps in resolving serious disputes quickly
  • Maintains balance between Centre and States
  • Has a major impact on laws and governance in India
• However, this power has a limitation. The Supreme Court will not have jurisdiction over disputes that arise from:
  • Any treaty, agreement, covenant, engagement, sanad, or similar arrangement
  • If such arrangements were made before the Constitution of India came into force (1950) and are still in effect, or
  • If the agreement itself clearly states that such disputes should not be handled by the Supreme Court

Appellate Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India

• Appellate jurisdiction refers to the power of the Supreme Court of India to hear and decide appeals against the judgments of lower courts, especially the High Courts. This means the Supreme Court does not hear the case for the first time, but reviews decisions already given.
• The Supreme Court acts as the highest court of appeal in India, so if a person is not satisfied with a High Court decision, they can approach the Supreme Court, making it the final authority in the judicial system.
• This jurisdiction covers constitutional, civil, and criminal matters, ensuring that laws are interpreted in a uniform manner across the country and that justice is consistently delivered.
• In constitutional matters (Article 132), an appeal can be made if the High Court certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law related to the interpretation of the Constitution, meaning the issue is serious and affects how the Constitution is understood.
• In civil matters (Article 133), an appeal is allowed when the High Court certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law of general importance, and that the matter should be decided by the Supreme Court. This ensures that only significant civil cases reach the Supreme Court.
• In criminal matters (Article 134), appeals can be made in serious situations, such as when the High Court:
  • Reverses a lower court’s decision of acquittal and sentences the accused to death, or
  • Takes up a case from a lower court and directly awards a death sentence.
• Under Article 136, the Supreme Court has a special power called Special Leave Petition (SLP), which allows it to hear appeals from any court or tribunal (except military courts). This is a discretionary power, meaning the Court can choose whether or not to accept the case, usually in situations where justice demands intervention.
• The Supreme Court mainly focuses on questions of law, meaning it checks whether legal principles were correctly applied. It usually does not re-examine all the facts unless there is a clear mistake or injustice.
• India has a three-tier judicial system – District Courts, High Courts, and the Supreme Court and appellate jurisdiction ensures a proper system of review at each level.
• In some cases, interlocutory appeals are allowed, which means appeals can be made against certain decisions during the ongoing trial, such as orders related to bail or evidence.
• The appellate jurisdiction of the Supreme Court is very important because it:
  • Helps in correcting errors made by lower courts
  • Ensures justice and fairness in decisions
  • Maintains uniform interpretation of laws across India
  • Strengthens the rule of law and constitutional values

‹ ›

Writ Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India

• Writ jurisdiction refers to the power of the Supreme Court of India to issue special legal orders called writs, which direct a person, authority, or government body to either do something or stop doing something, especially when someone’s rights are violated.
• This power is given under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, which is considered a very important provision because it allows citizens to directly approach the Supreme Court if their fundamental rights are violated.
• Dr. B. R. Ambedkar called Article 32 the “heart and soul” of the Constitution, as it provides a strong mechanism for the protection of rights.
• The Supreme Court can issue five types of writs, each serving a different purpose:
  • Habeas Corpus: This writ is used to protect personal liberty. It orders that a person who is detained must be brought before the court, and if the detention is illegal, the person must be released.
  • Mandamus: This writ is issued to compel a public authority or government official to perform a duty that they are legally required to perform but have failed or refused to do.
  • Prohibition: This writ is issued by a higher court to a lower court or tribunal to stop it from continuing proceedings in a case where it is acting beyond its powers or violating legal principles.
  • Certiorari: This writ is used to cancel or quash the order of a lower court or tribunal when it has acted without proper authority or violated the rules of natural justice.
  • Quo Warranto: This writ is used to question the legality of a person holding a public office, asking by what authority they are occupying that position.
• The writ jurisdiction of the Supreme Court plays a crucial role in:
  • Protecting fundamental rights of citizens
  • Ensuring that government authorities act within legal limits
  • Preventing misuse or abuse of power
  • Upholding the rule of law in the country
• However, this power is not exclusive to the Supreme Court. The High Courts of India also have the power to issue writs.
• There is an important difference between the powers of the Supreme Court and High Courts:
  • The Supreme Court can issue writs only for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights (Article 32).
  • High Courts can issue writs for Fundamental Rights as well as for other legal rights (Article 226).
• Because of this, the writ jurisdiction of High Courts is considered wider in scope, although the Supreme Court remains the highest authority.

Advisory Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of India

• Advisory jurisdiction means the power of the Supreme Court of India to give its opinion or advice on important legal or constitutional questions when such questions are referred to it by the President of India, mainly to help in decision-making at the highest level.
• This power is given under Article 143 of the Constitution of India, which allows the President to seek the Court’s opinion on any matter involving questions of law or fact that are of public importance or may affect the country as a whole, especially in situations where there is confusion or lack of clarity.
• Under this jurisdiction, the Supreme Court does not act like a regular court deciding disputes between parties; instead, it works in a consultative role, where it carefully examines the issue and provides its expert legal opinion to guide the executive.
• The President may refer matters to the Court in various situations, such as:
  • When there is doubt about the validity of a law, whether it is constitutional or not
  • When there is a need to interpret provisions of the Constitution clearly
  • When questions arise regarding the legality of ordinances or orders issued by the government
  • When there is confusion about the powers or jurisdiction of courts or authorities
  • When disputes arise from agreements, treaties, or arrangements made before the Constitution came into force in 1950
• There are broadly two kinds of references under this jurisdiction:
  • In matters of general public importance, the Supreme Court has the discretion to accept or refuse to give its opinion depending on whether it finds the issue suitable for judicial consideration
  • In matters related to pre-Constitution treaties or agreements, the Court is generally expected to give its opinion, as these often involve significant legal implications
• The opinion given by the Supreme Court under advisory jurisdiction:
  • Is not binding on the President or the government, meaning they are not legally required to follow it
  • However, it carries great authority and persuasive value, and is usually respected and followed in practice due to the Court’s position as the highest judicial body
• This jurisdiction plays an important role because it:
  • Helps in clearing legal and constitutional doubts before they turn into disputes
  • Assists the government in taking well-informed and legally sound decisions
  • Reduces the chances of future litigation and conflicts
  • Strengthens the working of the Constitution and governance system