Evolution of Civil Services in India - Civil Services During British Rule

16-05-2024

09:11 AM

1 min read

Evolution of Civil Services during British Rule

Prelims: History of India and the Indian National Movement

Mains: The Freedom Struggle — its various stages and important contributors/contributions from different parts of the country.

Evolution of Civil Services: By 1784, the East India Company’s administration of India had been brought under the control of the British Government. The needs of the British economy were determining its economic policies. In the beginning, the Company left the administration of its possessions in India in Indian hands, confining its activities to supervision. But it soon found that British aims were not adequately served by following old methods of administration. Consequently, the Company took some aspects of administration into its own hands.

Under Warren Hasting and Cornwallis, the administration at the top was overhauled, and the foundations of a new system of Civil Services based on the English pattern were laid down. The spread of British power to new areas led the nineteenth century to more fundamental changes in the system of administration. But the overall objectives of imperialism were never forgotten.

The British administration in India was based on main pillars like the Civil Service, the Army, the Police, the Judiciary etc. The rules, regulations and reforms in the administration paved the way for consolidating British rule in India.

Evolution of Civil Services during British Rule

The Civil Service was brought into existence by Lord Cornwallis (1786-93). From the beginning, East India Company (EIC) carried its trade through servants who later became administrations as the Company became a territorial power.

These servants were highly corrupt. By oppressing local weavers, artisans, merchants and zamindars, they amassed untold wealth with which they retired to England.
None of the Acts of Parliament between 1773 and 1793 looked into the education and training of Civil Servants in India.

The reformers and acts for civil services during British Rule were:

Reformer / Acts	Features / Recommendations
Cornwallis	- He was strict in upholding the laws prohibiting the official acceptance of gifts and bribes as well as private trade. - He increased the salary paid to the Company's employees. The Company's Civil Services actually rose to become the highest-paid profession worldwide. - He followed the policy of complete Europeanisation of Civil Services. - The Company's British covenanted servants filled all higher positions in Government service. - He laid down that promotion was by seniority. - The duties of different departments were defined. - Salaries were proportionate to responsibility.
Charter Act of 1793	- The Act provided the Charter or Rights of Civil Servants. - In accordance with its provisions, any vacancy in an Indian civil office "shall be filled from among the civil servants of the company belonging to the Presidency in which such vacancies occurred." - Despite enjoying patronage in England, the Act barred foreigners from entering the service. - The age requirement for hiring writers was raised to 22 years.
Lord Wellesley	- For the purpose of educating young recruits for the Civil Services, Lord Wellesley founded the College of Fort William in Calcutta in 1800. However, the directors of the Company disapproved of his action and, in 1806, replaced it with their own East Indian College at Haileybury in England.
The Charter Act of 1833	Suggested implementing a limited competitive exam. - Until 1853, Civil Service appointments were made by EIC directors, allowing Board of Control members some nominations.
The Charter Act of 1853	- It mandated that all Civil Service recruits would be chosen by way of a competitive examination.
Committee on the Indian Civil Service	- Also known as the Macaulay Committee, was established to advise on the measures to be adopted to give effect to the Act of 1853. The Committee set a certain age limit for admission to the College of Haileybury. It sought that the minimum and maximum age restrictions be raised to eighteen and twenty-five, respectively. The Committee suggested that candidates be chosen in accordance with the outcomes of a competitive examination. It also laid down that the examination should be so conducted to ensure the selection of candidates with thorough and not superficial knowledge. These recommendations were accepted by the Board of Control, and regulations were framed governing the examination and selection of candidates for the civil service. In 1856, the Board of Control held its first examination.
The Indian Civil Service Act of 1861	- It set aside a number of key positions for the Covenanted Service to fill. - Additionally, it stipulated that anyone, Indian or European, could be appointed to any of the positions listed in the schedule attached to the Act as long as they had lived in India for at least seven years. - For the district in which he was employed, a person had to pass a vernacular language examination. - The Indian public's increasing demand for the Indianisation of services was not met by the provisions of this Act. - The Act virtually remained a 'dead letter' largely because of the basic difficulty in implementing the recruitment requirements of the Act.
Statutory Civil Services (1879)	- The British Parliament passed an Act in 1870 authorising the appointment of any Indian to any office or the civil service without reference to the Act of 1861, which reserved specific appointments to the covenanted service. It also did not make the desired headway, as the opinion was divided on throwing open all civil appointments between Indians and Europeans in the tenure of higher offices. - In 1879, new regulations that created the Statutory Civil Service were drafted. It provided that a fifth of covenanted civil service posts were to be filled by the natives. Only Indians were eligible for appointment by local government, subject to government and secretary of state approval. Regrettably, the statutory system also failed to fulfil its original intent. The pressure for Indianisation increased after the Indian National Congress passed a resolution for concurrent civil service exams in England and India during its very first session in December 1885.
Aitchison Commission (1886)	- Tasked with creating a plan for admitting Indians to every branch of public service. - The Commission rejected the idea of changing the recruitment process for the covenanted civil service. - It suggested getting rid of the Statutory Civil Service and dividing the Civil Services into three categories: Imperial, Provincial, and Subordinate. As recommended, the Statutory Civil Service was abolished. - Additionally, it suggested reducing the number of scheduled positions reserved by the Act of 1861 for members of the covenanted Civil Service and transferring a specific number of positions to the provincial Civil Service. - Also, the term "covenanted Civil Service" was abolished, and the nation's civil services were now divided into three grades: Imperial, Provincial, and Subordinate. - The Secretary of State in Council was responsible for hiring for the superior positions within the Imperial Civil Service.
The Islington Commission (1912)	- In 1912, a Public Service Commission with Lord Islington as its chairman examined the issue of Indianisation. - The Commission observed that at that time, Indians constituted only 5% of the civil service. - The Commission supported two separate channels of access to the Indian Civil Service itself One in England- open to all alike One in India- Open to natives of India only. - By setting aside twenty-five per cent of the positions for Indians, or 189 out of 755 positions, it aimed to implement a strategy for promoting Indians to higher positions. - It proposed the categorization of the services under the Government of India into Class I and II. - No radical change in the structure of the organization of the civil service was envisaged by the Commission. - Also, it took nearly four years for it to submit the report. As a result, the proposed measures came to be regarded as inadequate by the enlightened Indians.
The Government of India Act, 1919	- It suggested categorizing services into three groups: All India Provincial, and Subordinate. - The term "All India Services" applied to all Imperial services that were then operating in the provinces, whether in the reserved or transferred departments. In terms of dismissal, pay, pensions, and other rights, All India Services employees received special protections. - The Act was proposed as a safeguard against political influence in the constitution by a Public Service Commission entrusted with the task of recruitment to the service. - In 1922, the first competitive examination was held under the supervision of the Civil Service Commission. - The Indian candidates chosen based on their performance were placed on two years of probation at an English university.
Lee Commission (Royal Commission, 1923)	- Over the negative British response towards the Indianisation of services, in 1923, a Royal Commission on Superior Civil Service in India under the chairmanship of Lord Lee was appointed. The Commission recommended the division of main services into three classes: All India, Central and Provincial. The Secretary of State should continue to have appointment and management authority over the All India Services, the Commission advised.
The Government of India Act, 1935	- As the Act of 1935 introduced provincial autonomy under responsible Indian Ministers, the rights and privileges of the members of the civil services were carefully protected. - Both the Governors and the Governor General had a special duty to safeguard the privileges and rights of the civil service. - It was provided that a civil servant was not to be dismissed from service by an authority below the rank of the officers who had appointed him. - The salaries, pensions, and emoluments were not subject to the vote of the legislature. - The Act also provided for the setting up of a Public Service Commission for the federation, Public Service Commission for each of the provinces, Joint Public Service Commission for two or more provinces. - As a result of the introduction of provincial autonomy under the Act, only three services, i.e. Indian Civil Service, the Indian Police Service and the Indian Medical Service were to continue as All India Services. - Recruitment to other All India Services like Indian Agricultural Service, Veterinary Service, Educational Service, Service of Engineers, and Forest were provincialized.

Since Cornwallis' time, the rigid and total exclusion of Indians from the Indian Civil Service has been a distinctive feature of it. The British were convinced that only English personnel could firmly establish an administration based on British ideas, institutions, and practices. The British lacked faith in the Indians' competence and morality. It was intentional for Indians to be excluded from the Civil Services. These services were necessary at the time because Indians could not be trusted to establish and maintain British rule in India. The Indian Civil Service, often referred to as the "steel frame," was instrumental in establishing and upholding British rule in India.

PYQs on Civil Services During British Rule

Question 1: Wellesley established the Fort William College at Calcutta because (UPSC Prelims 2020)

a) He was asked by the Board of Directors at London to do so

b) He wanted to revive interest in oriental learning in India

c) He wanted to provide William Carey and his associates with employment

d) He wanted to train British civilians for administrative purpose in India

Answer: (d)

Question 2: With reference to educational institutes during colonial rule in India, consider the following pairs: (UPSC Prelims 2018)

Institution Founder

Sanskrit College at Benaras William Jones
Calcutta Madrasa Warren Hastings
Fort William College Arthur Wellesley

Which of the pairs given above is/are correct?

a) 1 and 2

b) 2 only

c) 1 and 3

d) 3 only

Answer: (b)

FAQs on Evolution of Civil Services

Q) What were the civil services in India during British rule?

Civil services were split into covenanted and uncovenanted categories. The higher positions in the government were held by British civil servants, who made up the covenanted civil service. To make it easier for Indians to join the lower levels of government, the uncovenanted civil service was established.

Q) Which Indian personality became the first to join Civil Services under British India?

Satyendra Nath Tagore was the first Indian to enter the Indian Civil Service. He was put in charge of the Bombay ICS, where he served his entire career (1864–1897).

Q) What were the primary demands of the Indian National Congress (INC) about Civil Services?

The INC primarily wanted the Indianisation of Civil Services and holding exams in India.

Q) Who started British civil service in India?

The Civil Services in India are said to have been founded by Warren Hastings, but Charles Cornwallis is credited with reforming and modernising the Civil Services' internal structure. Charles Cornwallis earned the title "Father of Civil Service in India" as a result of his efforts.