Difference Between Moderates and Extremists, Key Points

The Indian National Congress saw two dominant ideologies during the freedom movement Moderates and Extremists. From 1885 to 1905, the Moderates, which was led by Dadabhai Naoroji and Gopal Krishna Gokhale relied on petitions, speeches, and dialogue with the British. But as their approach yielded limited results, and with the partition of Bengal in 1905, a more assertive and required mass participation. This marked the rise of the Extremists, whose influence grew from 1905 to around 1920.

Moderates

The Moderates was an ideology adopted during the early phase of the Indian National Congress (1885-1905). They believed in dialogue, diplomacy, and gradual reform. Leaders like Dadabhai Naoroji, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, and M.G. Ranade represented this group. Moderates relied on methods suggested by the constitution, petitions, resolutions, meetings, and deputations to bring changes and reform. They believed that the British government would listen to reason and introduce policies beneficial to Indians. 

Efforts by Moderates included demands for civil rights, expansion of the legislative councils, reduction in military expenditure, and greater Indian participation in administration.

However, their soft approach and slow progress frustrated the younger generation of nationalists, who later became the Extremists.

Extremists

The Extremists came into existence around 1905, during the Swadeshi Movement, which was sparked by the partition of Bengal. Leaders like Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal, and Lala Lajpat Rai believed in direct action and mass mobilisation.

They rejected the idea of pleasing the British and called for immediate self-rule (Swaraj). Extremists believed that real change could only come through boycotts, protests, strikes, and public movements. Their ideology was based on cultural rebirth, self-reliance, and inspiring national pride.

Unlike Moderates, the Extremists did not hesitate to criticise British rule openly and encouraged people to take pride in India’s heritage and fight for independence.

Difference Between Moderates and Extremists

Evolution of both Moderates and Extremists within the Indian National Congress reflected the political awareness which grew among Indians. Moderates aimed to bring about change through gradual reforms and cooperation with the British, whereas Extremists pushed for direct action and a stronger stance against colonial rule. The table below discusses the Difference Between Moderates and Extremists in a comparison manner to understand the two approaches in an easier manner.

‹ ›