Mains: History of the World will include events from the 18th century, such as Industrial Revolution, world wars, Redrawal of National Boundaries, Colonization, Decolonization, political philosophies like Communism, Capitalism, Socialism etc. their forms and effect on society.
French Revolution 1789
The French Revolution, spanning from 1789 to 1799, was a revolutionary movement that significantly impacted France and the world. Fueled by widespread discontent among the impoverished masses and the bourgeoisie over the gross inequalities and absolute power wielded by the monarchy, nobility, and clergy, this revolution marked a seismic shift in sociopolitical paradigms. The revolution witnessed the collapse of the monarchy, radical changes in the political landscape, and the rise of Napoleon Bonaparte. Its impact extended beyond France’s frontiers, inspiring nationalist movements worldwide. The French Revolution epitomised the core values of liberty, equality, and fraternity for all individuals.
France on the Eve of the Revolution
France was marked by deep-rooted social inequalities among the three estates, economic hardships, and political unrest, laying the groundwork for the transformative events that unfolded during the French Revolution.
French society: Eighteenth-century French society was divided into three estates.
First Estate: The clergy, which included bishops, priests, and other religious officials, enjoyed significant privileges and were exempt from taxation.
Second Estate: The nobility, comprising the aristocrats and members of the royal family, held vast lands and feudal rights over the peasantry. They too were exempted from paying taxes.
Third Estate: This estate encompassed the vast majority of the population, including the bourgeoisie (merchants and professionals), urban workers, and peasants. They bore the brunt of the tax burden imposed by the monarchy, fueling resentment towards the privileged classes.
This rigid social stratification, known as the "Old Regime," perpetuated inequalities and contributed to the mounting discontent that ultimately sparked the French Revolution.
French polity: France was an absolute monarchy, with King Louis XVI holding supreme power. The monarchy was considered divinely ordained, and the king ruled through a vast bureaucracy.
French economy: The French economy was primarily agricultural, with a significant portion of the population engaged in farming.
French Revolution Causes
Several factors contributed to the causes of the French Revolution:
Economic inequality: Most rural peasants lived in extreme poverty, struggling to make ends meet while shouldering heavy tax burdens. The clergy and nobility, meanwhile, were exempt from taxes and granted privileges.
Financial crisis: Years of extravagant spending by the monarchy, particularly King Louis XVI and the royal court, drained the state coffers and left the government heavily indebted.
Social injustice: The Third Estate, which comprised the majority of the population, faced inequality in terms of representation and political power.
They were burdened with heavy taxes and lacked social mobility, while the nobility and clergy enjoyed numerous privileges and monopolies.
Urban poor's resentment: The urban poor, facing unemployment, rising prices, and inadequate social welfare, grew increasingly resentful of the ruling regime and in resentment, they resorted to riots.
Enlightenment ideas: Enlightenment philosophies, which emphasised individual liberty, reason, and equality, had a significant influence on the intellectual climate in France. Thinkers such as Voltaire, Rousseau, and Montesquieu promoted ideas of individual liberty, reason, and equality, inspiring a new wave of progressive thought.
Voltaire criticised religious intolerance and championed freedom of speech and reason.
Rousseau expanded upon these ideas by proposing a form of government based on a social contract between people and their representatives.
Montesquieu in "The Spirit of the Laws," advocated for a division within the government into legislative, executive, and judicial branches as well as separation of power among them.
This model of government was put into practice in the United States following the colonies' declaration of independence from Britain.
The French intellectuals found great inspiration in the American Constitution and its protection of individual rights.
Influence of the American Revolution: The success of the American Revolution against British rule demonstrated that a determined population could overthrow a monarchy and establish a democratic government.
French leaders like Lafayate participated in the American Revolution, and they became the forebears of the revolution in France on their return.
Weak leadership: The monarchy under Louis XVI faced challenges due to weak leadership, a lack of decisive action, and a growing disconnect with the needs and aspirations of the population.
Queen Marie Antoinette: Her extravagant lifestyleand perceived indifference to the struggles of the French people aggravated public resentment. She was originally from Austria, which made her a foreign queenin the eyes of the French people. This fueled negative sentiments towards her and the monarchy.
French Revolution Outbreak
The Outbreak of the Revolution was caused by the particular actions of Louis XVI. They can be understood as below.
Louis XVI's need to increase taxes: XVI faced financial difficulties due to France's involvement in costly wars, such as the American Revolutionary War, which strained the royal treasury.
The existing tax system was outdated and inefficient, failing to generate sufficient revenue to meet the growing expenses of the monarchy.
Calling the Estates General: Louis XVI, as the monarch, did not possess the authority to unilaterally impose taxes. He had to convene a meeting of the Estates General, an assembly representing the three estates.
The Estates General had not been called for over two centuries, and Louis XVI took the initiative to summon the assembly on 5 May 1789 at Versailles.
Composition of the Estates General: The first and second estates sent 300 representatives each, while the third estate had 600 representatives, mainly comprising prosperous and educated individuals.
Peasants, artisans, and women were excluded from the assembly.
Demands of the Third Estate: The Third Estate members sought equal representation and demanded that voting in the Estates General be conducted by the assembly as a whole, with each member having one vote.
This demand aligned with democratic principles advocated by philosophers like Jean-Jacques Rousseau and his book "The Social Contract."
Important Events
Details
Tennis Court Oath
- Walkout: When Louis XVI rejected the Third Estate's demand for voting reform, the representatives of the Third Estate walked out of the assembly in protest.
- Tennis court oath: On 20 June 1789, they convened in the indoor tennis court at Versailles and declared themselves the National Assembly.
- The National Assembly swore not to disperse until a constitution was drafted to limit the powers of the monarch.
Storming of the Bastille
- A severe winter resulted in a bad harvest, leading to rising bread prices, hoarding, and exploitation by bakers.
- Angry women formed crowds and stormed into shops after enduring long queues at bakeries. Louis XVI deployed troops to Paris, further heightening tensions.
- On 14 July 1789, an agitated crowd stormed and destroyed the Bastille, a symbol of royal authority and oppression. This day is being celebrated as the Bastille Day or Independence Day of France.
National Assembly
- Peasant uprisings: Rumours spread in the countryside that lords of the manor had hired brigands to destroy crops, causing peasants to attack chateaux (castles) and seize hoarded grain.
Many nobles fled their homes and migrated to neighbouring countries in fear.
- Recognition of the National Assembly: Faced with the revolt of his subjects, Louis XVI recognised the National Assembly and accepted the need for a constitution to limit his powers.
- Reforms: On 4 August 1789, the Assembly passed a decree abolishing the feudal system, including obligations and taxes.
- Clergy: The clergy were also forced to relinquish their privileges, and church lands were confiscated, providing the government with significant assets worth at least 2 billion livres (French currency).
Constitution making
- The National Assembly drafted the constitution in 1791, by which France became a constitutional monarchy.
The objective of the Constitution:
The main objective was to limit the powers of the monarch and establish a system of governance that separated and distributed powers among different institutions.
Separation of powers: The Constitution assigned powers to different institutions, namely the legislature, executive, and judiciary. This separation ensured a system of checks and balances, preventing any one entity from having excessive control.
Legislative power: The Constitution vested the power to make laws in the National Assembly, which was indirectly elected.
National Assembly: Citizens voted for a group of electors, who then selected members of the Assembly.
Limited suffrage: Men over 25 who paid taxes equal to at least three days' worth of labourer's wages were deemed to be active citizens and were therefore eligible to vote.
The rest of the men and all women were classified as passive citizens, meaning they did not possess voting rights.
Major Events after the French Revolution
The French Revolution witnessed a series of major events that transformed France and had far-reaching consequences, including the formation of state constitutions, political party development, the rise of Napoleon, and the spread of revolutionary ideals across the nation.
Revolutionary Wars
Despite signing the Constitution, Louis XVI engaged in secret negotiations with the King of Prussia. The rulers of neighbouring countries were concerned about the developments in France and made plans to send troops to suppress the events taking place since 1789.
Declaration of War: In April 1792, the National Assembly voted to declare war against Prussia and Austria.
Declaration of Volunteers: Thousands of provincial volunteers enlisted in the army, viewing it as a popular war against European monarchies and aristocracies.
Impact of the wars: The Revolutionary Wars resulted in losses and economic hardships for the population.
Men were away fighting, leaving women to shoulder the responsibilities of earning a living and caring for their families.
Many people believed that the revolution needed to go further, as the Constitution of 1791 granted political rights only to the wealthier sections of society.
Political Clubs
The first anniversary of the fall of the Bastille marked a moment of liberation and exaltation. There was a general feeling of unity and solidarity among the participants. It was seen as a significant step towards a more inclusive society.
Discontent: However, this sense of unity did not last long. The common people continued to suffer, and dissatisfaction grew among them.
Political clubs: Dissatisfied people started forming political clubs to discuss the problems they faced.
Jacobin Club: One such club which attained popularity was the Jacobin Club in Paris. The members were from poor sections of society – small-scale business people, artisans, servants and wage labourers. Their leader was Maximilian Robespierre, a French lawyer and statesman.
A majority of the members of the Jacobin club wore long striped trousers as against the trousers with knee breeches usually worn by the noble class.
Cordelier Club: Another lawyer, Danton, dominated the Cordelier Club.
National Convention and Birth of the First French Republic
The Jacobins organised an uprising during the summer of 1792 in reaction to high prices and a lack of food. In August, they stormed the Palace of the Tuileries, overpowered the king's guards, and held the king hostage.
The Assembly subsequently voted to imprison the royal family, and elections were held. The newly elected assembly, known as the Convention, abolished the monarchy in September 1792 and declared France a republic.
Louis XVI was sentenced to death for treason and publicly executed on January 21, 1793, followed by the execution of Queen Marie Antoinette.
The Reign of Terror
The period from 1793 to 1794 is known as the Reign of Terror, characterised by severe control and punishment under the leadership of Maximilien Robespierre.
Robespierre targeted people he believed to be republican enemies, such as clergy, ex-nobles, people in other political parties, and even his own party's dissidents.
Those deemed guilty were arrested, imprisoned, and tried by revolutionary tribunals, with a high likelihood of being sentenced to death by guillotine.
Economic and social changes: Robespierre's government implemented laws to control the economy, such as placing maximum ceilings on wages and prices.
Meat and bread were rationed, and peasants were forced to carry their grain to cities where it was sold for prices set by the government.
Churches were closed, and their buildings were repurposed as barracks or offices.
The downfall of Robespierre: Over time, even Robespierre's supporters began to call for moderation in his policies. Eventually, he was convicted by a court in July 1794, arrested, and executed by guillotine.
Rule of the Directory
The fall of the Jacobin government allowed the wealthier middle classes to come to power.A new constitution was introducedthat restricted voting rights to property-owning sections of society, excluding non-propertied individuals.
Introduction of the Directory: The legislative councils appointed a Directory, which consisted of five members and served as the executive branch of the government. The creation of the Directory aimed to prevent the concentration of power in a single individual, as had been the case under the Jacobins.
Instability of the Directory: The Directors often clashed with the legislative councils, leading to conflicts and attempts to dismiss them. The political instabilitywithin the Directory created a sense of discontent and dissatisfaction among the people.
Rise of Napoleon Bonaparte: The political instability and power struggles within the Directory created an opportunity for military leaders to seize control. Napoleon Bonaparte emerged as a military dictator and eventually took power, marking the end of the Directory.
French Revolution Impacts
The French Revolution had a profound impact not only in France but also throughout Europe, serving as a source of inspiration for anti-colonial intellectuals and movements worldwide during the 19th and early 20th centuries.
Reduction of Social Inequality: The revolution aimed to reduce social inequality by curbing privileges based on birth.
Republican government: A republican form of government with electoral rights was established, replacing the monarchy.
Abolition of the feudal system: The feudal system was abolished, which perpetuated social hierarchies and obligations.
Abolition of slavery: Although it took time for the total abolition of slavery, the French Revolution played a pivotal role in bringing about its eventual demise.
Subordination of the Church: The Church lost its supremacy and became subordinate to the state.
Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen: The Declaration underscored the significance of both individual and collective rights.
It championed principles such as liberty, equality, and fraternity, shaping the course of history and inspiring subsequent movements for justice and freedom.
Separation of powers: It resulted in establishing a system with three separate organs of government: legislative, executive, and judiciary.
Inspiration for Europe: It sparked hope across Europe, inspiring people to challenge despotic rule and strive for the establishment of egalitarian societies.
American Revolution vs French Revolution
Aspect
American Revolution
French Revolution
Causes
Colonialism, Taxation without representation, restriction of civil liberties by British rule
Social inequality, fiscal crisis, abuse of privileges by nobility and clergy
Ideological Basis
Principles of natural rights, individual interest, republicanism
Ideals of liberty, equality, fraternity, collective rights, general will, social contracts, etc.
Goals
Independence from British rule, self-governance, individual interests, limited government, etc.
Reform of the absolute monarchy, the establishment of a constitutional government, collective interests, general will, social justice, etc.
Outcomes
Establishment of a federal republic government, the United States of America
Abolition of the monarchy, and establishment of a republic (later the Napoleonic Empire)
Leadership
Figures like George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin
Figures like Maximilien Robespierre, Georges Danton, Napoleon Bonaparte
Inspiration
Inspired by English liberals and Enlightenment thinkers like John Locke, Thomas Paine, etc.
Inspired by radical French thinkers like Voltaire, Rousseau, Montesquieu, etc.
Global Impact
Inspired revolutions in Latin America and Europe, promoted democratic ideals
Spread of revolutionary ideals across Europe, rise of nationalism, secularism
On Slavery
Did not end slavery. It was dismantled after the Civil War.
Slavery was initially made illegal in 1794 in colonies, however, it was only in 1848 that it was completely dismantled.
Question 1: Explain how the foundations of the modern world were laid by the American and French revolutions. (UPSC Mains exam 2019)
French Revolution FAQs
Why is the French Revolution important?
The French Revolution is important because it marked a pivotal turning point in history, challenging the existing social and political order and setting the stage for the rise of democratic principles and ideals worldwide.
Who is called the child of the French Revolution?
Napoleon Bonaparte is often referred to as the "child of the French Revolution" due to his rise to power and subsequent consolidation of authority, which was made possible by the revolutionary changes and upheavals in France.
When did the French Revolution begin?
The French Revolution began on July 14, 1789, with the storming of the Bastille prison in Paris, which is widely regarded as a symbolic event and the initial catalyst for the revolution.
When did the French Revolution end?
The French Revolution is generally considered to have ended with the rise to power of Napoleon Bonaparte in 1799, specifically with the establishment of the Consulate. This marked the consolidation of authority and the transition from the revolutionary period to the Napoleonic era.
Why did the French Revolution start?
The French Revolution started due to a combination of socioeconomic inequality, resentment towards the monarchy, and Enlightenment ideals promoting liberty and equality, with the catalyst being the economic crisis and food shortages faced by the French government.