13-11-2024
07:40 AM
GS I
Sub-Categories:
Ancient History Notes for UPSC
Table of Contents
Prelims: History of India
Mains: Indian Culture-Salient aspects of Art Forms, Literature and Architecture from ancient to modern times
Jainism vs Buddhism: The prevalent social, economic, and religious circumstances during the sixth century B.C. gave rise to new religious churning in Indian society. The Vedic ritualistic, orthodox ideas and the prevalence of rigid caste realities were coming under increasing attack during this period. As a result, numerous heterodox religious movements eventually emerged. Amongst them, Buddhism and Jainism were the most important ones that successfully evolved into the well-organised popular religions.
The emergence of Jainism and Buddhism shares some similarities in their principles; however, they differ significantly in some fundamental aspects.
Concept | Buddhism | Jainism |
Basic Doctrines |
- The Eight-Fold Path:
| - Pancha Mahavratas:
- Triratnas: According to Jainism, a person can achieve "moksha" by leading a life of purity, virtue, and renunciation. The following principles (triratnas or ratnatraya) can be followed to achieve moksha (nirvana):
|
Belief in Soul | - Buddhism denies the concept of self (jiva) or soul (atman), proposing the concept of no-self (anatta) instead. - Buddhism does not believe in the transmigration of the soul either. | - Jains believe in the existence of an eternal Jiva (soul). - They believe in the transmigration of the soul. |
Non-violence doctrine | - Buddhism takes a moderate path to non-violence. It prohibits violence but is not as strict as Jainism. - For example, it even permits eating animal flesh, if necessary or as part of the local diet. | - The doctrine of nonviolence ('Ahimsa') is being strictly followed by Jainism. - For instance, Jain vegetarianism is based on the idea that no animal should be harmed. - They also prohibit agriculture because they believe that it can kill insects and pests. |
Salvation | - Buddhism advises its Upasakas to follow the middle path to attain salvation (Nirvana). - Nirvana is possible during one’s own life through the practice of detachment from worldly desires and ignorance. - According to Buddhism, it is possible for both normal men and women to attain salvation. | - Jainism advises the practice of strict asceticism to attain salvation, that is Kaivalya. - According to Jainism, salvation is possible only after death. - According to Jainism, women and male householders cannot attain salvation. |
The existence of God | - The Buddha neither accepted nor rejected the existence of God. He was more concerned about the individual and his actions. | - Jainism recognises the existence of God. - For example, in Jainism, pantheons of gods, including the Brahmanical gods, are worshipped. |
Karma | - The concept of 'karma' law is highly valued in Buddhism. - This law states that past acts determine the present. | - They also believe in Karma. - According to Jains, karma is a real substance that permeates the entire universe. - The actions of the soul draw karma particles to the soul. |
Philosophical concepts | - Madhyamika: Also known as Sunyavada and was systematised by Nagarjuna (2nd century A.D) - The name of this school comes from Buddha’s famous ‘middle position’ (madhyama pratipad). - The middle position is the rejection of the extreme metaphysical positions of ‘is’ and ‘is not’ (Sasvatavada and Uchedavada). - Thus it becomes the no-position (transcendental and inexpressible) and they used the word ‘Sunyata’ to explain it. | - Anekantwada: Realistic and relativistic pluralism is what the doctrine of the manyness of reality proposes. A thing can have an infinite number of unique characteristics.
- Syadvada: The doctrine of Jaina metaphysics, which is expressed by the word syat (Sanskrit: "maybe"), holds that all judgements are conditional and valid only under specific circumstances, senses, or conditions.
|
Buddhism:
Jainism:
Buddhism:
Jainism:
While Buddhism has practically vanished from India, the land of its birth, Jainism is still a prominent religion, albeit in small numbers.
Question 1: With reference to Indian history, consider the following texts: (UPSC Prelims 2022)
Which of the above are Jaina texts?
Answer: (b)
Question 2: With reference to the religious practices in India, the "Sthanakvasi" sect belongs to (UPSC Prelims 2018)
Answer: (b)
Question 3: With reference to the religious history of India, consider the following statements (UPSC Prelims 2017)
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (b)
Question 4: Which of the following statements is/are applicable to Jain doctrine? (UPSC Prelims 2013)
Select the correct answer using the codes given below.
Answer: (d)
Question 5: Which one of the following describes best the concept of Nirvana in Buddhism? (UPSC Prelims 2013)
Answer: (a)
Buddhism was founded by Gautama Buddha. 24 Tirthankaras are credited with the foundation and development of Jainism and its philosophy; however, Parsvanatha and Mahavira are more important due to their historical records and their influence on the main two sects of Jainism.
Buddhism denies the concept of self (jiva) or soul (atman), proposing the concept of no-self (anatta) instead. Jains believe in the existence of an eternal Jiva (soul).
The Buddha neither accepted nor rejected the existence of God. He was more concerned about the individual and his actions. Jainism recognises the existence of God.
Buddhism advises its Upasakas to follow the middle path, or Tathagata marg, to attain salvation. Jainism advises the practice of strict asceticism to attain salvation.
© 2024 Vajiram & Ravi. All rights reserved